The contrato de arras, the Spanish preliminary purchase contract signed when the buyer pays a deposit, sets out the terms of a sale and the sum the buyer pays as a deposit (señal) or payment on account. The amount is agreed between the parties, although the usual practice is to pay 10% of the price. Before signing, you need to tell the difference between arras penitenciales, confirmatorias and penales, because their effects are different.
In Catalonia, article 621-8 of the Catalan Civil Code presumes that the payment is confirmatory. For a party to have the right to withdraw by forfeiting the arras or paying them back double, arras penitenciales must be expressly agreed. That is why it is advisable to review the content of the contract and the applicable law before handing over any money.
The arras are the sum paid by the buyer as part of the sale. The document known as the contrato de arras usually sets out the property, the price, the deadline for signing the title deed and the consequences of withdrawal or breach. Its scope depends on what has been agreed, not just on the title at the top of the document.
This agreement serves three purposes at once:
It is advisable to sign them once the essential terms have been agreed and the key checks have been carried out. A possible sequence is as follows:
The preliminary checks are especially important. In our guide on what to look for when buying a house, we explain what to check before committing any money.
When the Spanish Civil Code applies, article 1454 governs arras penitenciales. The consequences of breach and of penalty clauses are linked, among others, to articles 1124, 1152 and 1153.
Book six of the Catalan Civil Code regulates arras in article 621-8 and financing by a lender in article 621-49. In transactions on the Costa Brava, it is advisable to check the applicable law expressly, especially if foreign buyers or sellers are involved. Whether another law can be chosen, and within what limits, depends on the conflict-of-law rules; it is not enough to change a reference in a template.
The contract should state whether it allows withdrawal or whether the parties remain bound to buy and sell, and what financial consequences have been agreed. Identifying the type of arras and the applicable rule helps to avoid doubts, although citing an article is no substitute for a clear clause.
Arras penitenciales allow both parties to withdraw on the agreed terms. If the buyer withdraws, they forfeit the amount paid. If the seller withdraws, they must pay it back double: the deposit received plus an equal amount. In Catalonia there is an exception when financing is refused, which we explain below.
Their advantage is that they fix the cost of withdrawing. If one party validly exercises that right, the other cannot demand that the sale go ahead simply because the first party has changed its mind. It is a different matter if a breach or the application of another condition in the contract is in dispute.
Arras confirmatorias evidence the sale and act as a payment on account. They do not in themselves grant a right to withdraw. In the event of a breach, the other party can demand performance or, where the legal requirements are met, terminate the contract. They can also claim the damages that are due and that they can prove.
They provide a firmer commitment to complete, but they do not in themselves set an amount of compensation or guarantee that a dispute can be resolved without a claim.
Arras penales set a financial consequence for breach. Paying the penalty does not in itself release a party from the obligation to buy or sell, unless that possibility has been agreed. The possibility of claiming both the penalty and performance must be clearly provided for, in accordance with article 1153 of the Spanish Civil Code, where it applies.
| Feature | Penitenciales | Confirmatorias | Penales |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free withdrawal | Yes, with the agreed effects and the applicable exceptions | Not simply by paying the deposit | Not by paying the penalty, unless a release clause has been agreed |
| If the buyer withdraws or breaches | If they validly withdraw, they forfeit the deposit, unless there are grounds for repayment | The seller can demand performance or termination where appropriate, plus damages | The agreed penalty applies; combining it with performance must be clearly provided for |
| If the seller withdraws or breaches | If they validly withdraw, they pay back double the deposit | The buyer can demand performance or termination where appropriate, plus damages | The agreed penalty applies; paying it does not in itself release the seller |
| Reference rules | Art. 621-8.2 CCCat or art. 1454 CC, depending on the applicable law | Art. 621-8.1 and remedies under the CCCat; art. 1124 CC where appropriate | Agreed clause; arts. 1152 and 1153 CC where appropriate |
| Express agreement | Required for penitenciales in Catalonia | In Catalonia, a payment on account is presumed confirmatory | The penalty and its effects must be clearly defined |
Article 621-8 of the Catalan Civil Code contains two rules that every seller and buyer on the Costa Brava should know before signing:
Do not assume that forfeiting the deposit is enough to walk away. If the arras are confirmatorias, the other party can demand performance or termination on the terms provided for by law.
If Catalan law applies, the contract must state that the buyer intends to finance all or part of the purchase price. Article 621-49 allows the buyer to withdraw, unless otherwise agreed, if they provide documentary proof, within the agreed deadline, that the financing applied for, or the takeover of the existing mortgage, has been refused. The refusal must not be the result of their own negligence. When the requirements are met, the amount paid must be returned, including, where applicable, the arras penitenciales.
This protection has its limits:
So needing a mortgage does not in itself guarantee that the deposit will be returned. The buyer must state in the contract their intention to finance all or part of the purchase, and the deadline and consequences of a refusal must be clear. Nor should the seller assume that every refusal allows them to keep the arras.
For the seller, the arras turn an "I'm interested" into a commitment with financial consequences. These are the specific protections:
Before signing, it is advisable to check the planned financing or available funds and agree a realistic deadline. A mortgage agreement in principle is only indicative and is not the same as final approval of the loan. You should also check how a refusal of financing is dealt with. On our page about how to sell your house on the Costa Brava, we explain how we support property owners.
The seller also has obligations: they must honour the sale while it is in force, hand over the property in the agreed condition and with the agreed charges and occupancy, and provide the necessary paperwork. If they have a right to withdraw, they must exercise it on the agreed terms. You can find out more in our list of documents needed to sell a house in Spain.
For the buyer, the contract fixes the price and the terms of the transaction. In places such as Begur, Calella de Palafrugell or Llafranc, it is advisable to make clear from when the property is taken off the market and what commitments the seller is making.
Before signing, you need to check the ownership and powers of those involved. If it is the family home, check the consent of the non-owning spouse required by article 231-9; the rule extends to stable unmarried couples under article 234-3. If the property comes from an inheritance, check that the estate has been accepted and the property awarded, what rights exist over it and who must take part, in person or through a sufficient power of attorney.
There is no compulsory legal percentage for the arras. The usual practice is to pay 10% of the price, although the parties can agree a different amount. With arras penitenciales, a low deposit reduces the cost of withdrawing for both parties; a high one increases the buyer's financial exposure if they forfeit it and the seller's if they have to pay it back double.
Example with a villa in Begur sold for €1,200,000 and arras of 10% (€120,000):
| What happens | Arras penitenciales | Arras confirmatorias |
|---|---|---|
| The sale is completed | The €120,000 is deducted: €1,080,000 remains | The €120,000 is deducted: €1,080,000 remains |
| The buyer wants to pull out with no grounds for repayment | If they validly withdraw, they forfeit €120,000 | Forfeiting the deposit does not release them: performance or termination can be demanded where appropriate, plus damages |
| The seller wants to pull out | If they validly withdraw, they pay back €240,000 in total | The buyer can demand performance or termination where appropriate; on termination, repayment and any damages due |
| The bank refuses the financing | Recovery of €120,000 if art. 621-49 applies and all its requirements are met, with no agreement to the contrary | Same protection if art. 621-49 applies and all its requirements are met, with no agreement to the contrary |
The seller should also budget for the costs and taxes of the transaction and, if there is a mortgage to be redeemed, how it will be paid off and the charge removed from the Land Registry.
The parties agree the deadline for signing the deed. They might agree, for example, one, two or three months, depending on the outstanding formalities. If the date is approaching and cannot be met, it is advisable to agree an extension in writing before it expires. What happens when the deadline passes depends on whether it is essential, what was agreed and how the parties have acted; do not assume that the contract automatically ends or is extended.
On the Costa Brava, it is advisable to tailor the deadline to the reality of each transaction:
A contrato de arras for a home should include at least the following:
A template can serve as a starting point, but it must be adapted to the applicable law, the type of arras and the circumstances of the transaction. Clauses on financing and repayment of the money require particular attention.
Many properties on the Costa Brava have particular features that a standard contract does not cover. These clauses can prevent a dispute between signing the arras and going to the notary.
For any house, masía (traditional Catalan farmhouse) or other building, it is advisable to compare the actual property with the Land Registry, the Cadastre and the town council's records, whether it stands on urban or non-developable land. A building being registered or recorded in the Cadastre does not in itself settle its planning status. If a check is decisive, the condition should define what documents will be obtained, what result is considered acceptable, the deadline and what happens to the deposit. This review is especially relevant when considering country houses for sale on the Costa Brava.
For homes near the sea, including areas such as Sa Tuna, Aiguablava or Tamariu, you need to check the coastal boundary and the restrictions under the Ley de Costas (Spanish Coastal Law). Inclusion in the public domain and the easements have different effects; they can affect the rights over the property, its use and any building work. The specific situation must be clarified before making a final financial commitment.
If the purchase depends on holiday lettings, you need to check the tourist use authorisation, its validity, the town council's conditions and the procedure for the change of holder of the activity. The tourist registration number does not, on its own, guarantee that the letting can continue. You should also check whether the municipality is affected by the specific planning licence and its transitional regime. The contract should specify what is to be checked, within what deadline and what happens if the agreed result is not obtained.
For a building plot, it is advisable to check the land classification and zoning, permitted uses, buildability and the conditions needed to carry out the planned project. If the purchase depends on that feasibility, the condition should define the required result and the consequences if it is not proven within the deadline. You can browse our selection of land on the Costa Brava.
The consequences depend on the type of arras and the reason for the breach:
As a general rule, the arras do not need to be signed before a notary: they can be set out in a valid private document. The public deed of sale provides the guarantees explained by the General Council of Spanish Notaries and allows the sale to be entered in the Land Registry, but it should not be mistaken for a universal requirement for any sale to exist. If a specific notarial or registry guarantee is wanted for the arras, its scope and cost should be assessed.
The deed must identify the means of payment, including any amounts paid earlier as arras. That is why it is advisable to pay by bank transfer and keep proof of payment.
For an individual's IRPF (Spanish income tax), simply paying or receiving a deposit on account does not in itself give rise to a capital gain or loss. The treatment depends on how the transaction ends. The Spanish Tax Agency's income tax manual distinguishes the following cases:
| Outcome | Seller | Buyer |
|---|---|---|
| The sale is completed | The deposit forms part of the price; the gain or loss on the sale is calculated under the IRPF rules | The deposit forms part of the acquisition price |
| The buyer forfeits the arras by withdrawing | The amount kept is classed as a capital gain in the general income base, in the relevant tax year | The capital loss is included in the general base in line with the criterion in the income tax manual |
This IRPF explanation does not mean that every advance payment is free of tax consequences: if the sale is subject to IVA (Spanish VAT) and not exempt, an advance payment on account of the price can make the tax due when it is received, under article 75.Dos of the VAT Act.
The three terms are often used as synonyms, but they are not the same:
Before handing over any money, ask for the document to state what happens to it if the transaction does not go ahead.
Before paying a deposit, you need to be clear about what you are signing, when the sale must be completed and in what cases the money is returned or lost. At Costa Brava House we support property sales in Begur, Pals, Palafrugell and the rest of the Empordà. Our property legal services include preparing and supervising contracts.
If you want to sell a property, you can request a valuation. If you are looking to buy, browse our properties for sale on the Costa Brava.
This article is for information only and is no substitute for legal or tax advice on a specific transaction.